Hero Banner

Modern Workplace Discussions

Discuss best practices related to Security, Teamwork and Unified Endpoint Management (Microsoft 365).

Reply
Johnmn
Visitor 1

Server 2019 Essentials user licensing limitation

I have an environment where Windows 2019 Essentials is the domain controller. There are 9 user accounts in the environment. The SILSVC logs state that there are 43 user accounts in the AD and that licensing is in violation. This status causes the Essentials DC to shutdown once every 7 days.

 

Investigation has shown that the variation between the 9 user accounts and the 43 reported is accounts created for services attached to applications in the environment. With Essentials 2016 there was a way to not include accounts created for services from the licensing count by hiding them from the GUI management application using set-wssuserdashboardvisibility.

 

With Windows server 2019 Essentials is there a way to not include accounts created for services in the count of users toward the 25 user account limit?

6 REPLIES 6
DSPatrick
Level 6 Contributor

I'm wondering why would 34 different service accounts be required? Maybe you can consolodate them into some lesser number?

 

 

JanoschUlmer
Microsoft

Well, the Product Terms state for Essentials server edition explicitly "25 user accounts" - emphasis is on the word "accounts". For all other products, like CAL, normal Windows Server etc there is no rule specific to the (technical) account, but only the "user" - defined as the person. So from a licensing perspective I tend to say that even when you would be able to do what you described technically, it does not change the fact that there are more accounts as license terms allows.

 

Relevant text in Product Terms (https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/Licensing/product-licensing/products😞

"Customer may use up to 25 user accounts. Each user account permits a named user to access and use the server software on that server."

 

And - the same statement was there for Windows Server 2016 Essentials btw.

Kind regards, Janosch
Receive consultations via Technical Presales and Deployment Services team
Velox
Visitor 1

'User account' = an account being used by a user. I would read it as the opposite. They should not be counting accounts not used by users if they're just servicing something on the system. I.E. we have separate admin and user accounts as we don't want to be administering the server using a normal user account (I.E. the recommended way to do this). MS should not be counting those accounts when considering the licence. I am one person, it should not matter that I need two accounts. This kind of behaviour just forces people to hack the licence service and stop it then manage licences themselves.

JanoschUlmer
Microsoft

Even if you hack the license service, it does not change the rules in the product terms, plus it puts you in an unsupported state. If this does not fit for your purpose, the other option is to go for a normal Windows Server for the product terms allow exactly the scenario you mentioned.

 

 

Kind regards, Janosch
Receive consultations via Technical Presales and Deployment Services team
samlhc
Visitor 1

I only have 5 accounts defined to a Windows 2019 Essentials server.  Where can I find the number of accounts that the OS is

and shutting down the server every 7 days?

JanoschUlmer
Microsoft

@samlhc I'm not sure I understand - you can look up the number of accounts the current server is configured for in the same area where you have defined the user accounts. When the server is shutting down every 7 days, and only 5 accounts are created it might also be to other reasons (e.g. you moved FSMO role from the server).

Kind regards, Janosch
Receive consultations via Technical Presales and Deployment Services team